How to Choose a Medical Journal: Scope, Indexing, APC Waivers, and Article-Type Limits
By Trace.Science Editorial Board
Select a target journal before finalizing manuscript formatting by matching your study design (RCT, retrospective cohort, systematic review, diagnostic AI, case report) against verified article-type constraints, confirming indexing in NLM Catalog / MEDLINE / DOAJ, checking whether your institution holds a read-and-publish APC agreement or if a Diamond OA ($0 APC) venue fits, and preparing a ranked 3-journal cascade.
1. Match Article Type and Word/Display Constraints First
Many desk rejections or immediate administrative returns happen because an author submits a 4,200-word manuscript with 8 figures to a venue that caps Original Investigations at 3,000 words and 5 display items (such as JAMA Network journals), or submits a narrative review to a venue requiring PRISMA 2020 registration.
- Concise Clinical Formats (2,500–3,000 words, max 4–5 tables/figures): JAMA & JAMA Network specialty journals, NEJM (2,700 words), The Journal of Urology (2,500 words), JAAD (2,500 words), Critical Care Medicine (3,000 words).
- Extended Clinical & Translational Formats (4,000–5,000+ words): Circulation (5,000 words), JACC (4,500–5,000 words), Brain (6,000 words), PLOS Medicine, BMC Medicine, JMIR.
- Research Letters / Brief Reports (600–1,200 words, 1–2 displays): High-yield format for focused single-center cohorts or negative findings in top-tier specialty venues.
2. Understand Open Access vs. Hybrid vs. Diamond OA ($0 APC)
Never confuse mandatory Gold Open Access APCs with optional Hybrid Open Access fees:
- Hybrid Journals (e.g., JAMA, NEJM, Lancet, Circulation, JACC, Radiology, Annals of Surgery): Traditional subscription publication costs $0 in APCs. The $4,000–$11,000 APC only applies if you elect optional immediate Gold Open Access.
- Gold Open Access with Waivers (e.g., PLOS ONE, JAMA Network Open, BMC series, JMIR): Charge an APC upon acceptance, but offer Research4Life LMIC waivers and institutional transformative agreements.
- Diamond Open Access ($0 APC to Author, $0 to Reader): Journals such as Journal of Graduate Medical Education (JGME), Annals of Family Medicine, Emerging Infectious Diseases (CDC), and Journal of Open Source Software (JOSS) charge zero fees.